Reviews and Press

"Pennington is one of those few writers who moves easily between time and place, weaving stories from history and the present day, in places familiar and exotic. But one thing unites all his work: strong characters, plots that move, pages that turn. No matter the when or where, when it comes to storytelling, Pennington delivers."

- James L. Nelson, author of The Norsemen Saga

West of the Alleghenies

"Pennington writes with humor and shows a good understanding of the era. The depth of his research about the American Revolution, the Native Americans of the East, and many aspects of daily frontier life leaves a sense that we know what the characters are experiencing."

- Muzzleloader Magazine

The Historical Novel Society Reviews

The Shadows of Havana

Pennington has imagined a fresh tale, of interest to fans of Hemingway and those interested in Cuban political history. Readers will appreciate the foreshadowing and root for Evans to evade thugs and gunfire, to secure incriminating photos, and to get those photos out of the country safely...On the whole, I commend Pennington for a creative mixture of fact and fiction.

The Heart of the Run

While we are learning so much, we are also experiencing a well-written novel full of suspense, heartache, romance, and intrigue. Readers will be swept away to other times and places by these stories within a story. Those interested in European history will enjoy this captivating novel.

West of the Alleghenies

Adventure stories whose characters endure extreme physical hardships tend to make me dismayed at my own shortcomings; I don’t think I would have the guts or grit to endure what they did. Fergus’s fortitude helps him endure starvation, freezing half-naked, witnessing atrocities, and months of not knowing his family’s fate. Pennington has done extensive research and provides footnotes (such as why he chose to use the controversial “squaw”), a map, and a bibliography. He also explains the changes he made for drama’s sake from the historical record. I recommend this well-researched and stirring Revolutionary adventure.

Murder on the Underground Railroad

This is so much more than a mystery. It is a look back at a struggle between good and evil in the United States. The author does not back away from horrifying moments in history, and rightly so.

Book Review: Murder on the Underground Railroad

Author: Craig Pennington

Reviewer: Jonathan Bogert, Director, Historical & Genealogical Society of Indiana County

Craig Pennington’s Murder on the Underground Railroad is a gripping historical thriller that masterfully blends suspense, history, and intrigue into a compelling narrative. With a focus on Indiana County’s rich past, this 294-page novel dives deep into the lives of its characters while exploring themes of justice, morality, and societal change.

The story begins with a series of unfortunate murders, introducing readers to Moses Moorhead—a resilient newspaperman—and his trusted friend Dr. Robert Mitchell. Together, they uncover sinister activities linked to the Western Pennsylvania community, drawing readers into a web of danger and conspiracy. The duo’s determination to protect their town and unravel the truth drives the plot forward, highlighting their courage and resourcefulness.

Pennington’s vivid descriptions transport readers to 19th-century Indiana County and Philadelphia, immersing them in the sights, sounds, and struggles of the era. The author’s attention to historical detail adds authenticity to the narrative, while the suspenseful pacing keeps readers engaged. From courtroom drama to daring escapes, every twist and turn feels both thrilling and historically grounded.

What sets this book apart is its ability to seamlessly weave historical facts with fictional storytelling. Pennington skillfully incorporates elements of the Underground Railroad and societal tensions, creating a nuanced portrayal of the time period. The novel strikes a fine balance between action-packed sequences and thoughtful reflection on human behavior.

While some may find certain aspects of historical accuracy slightly adjusted for dramatic effect, this serves to enhance the storytelling without detracting from its overall impact. The book’s exploration of themes like loyalty, sacrifice, and justice resonates deeply, leaving readers with much to ponder long after turning the final page.